This recipe, before changes, came from the McCall’s Cooking School. It serves 6-8. The dumplings are a nice touch and differentiate this recipe from others you might know. Because of the dumplings, this is not served over noodles or rice. The original recipe, in my opinion, had insufficient chicken, and I also switched from white to dark meat as the dark meat is more forgiving and can survive over-cooking (who would do that?).
This recipe has a lot of vegetables, and I have put in what I like. You can certainly change them. Some Chicken Fricassee recipes call for wine. You can replace some of the water with red wine if you wish. I also make it a bit spicy, and this, too, can be adjusted.
Many will toss the chicken in flour. I prefer to use pancake mix which contains some other ingredients. I use the same strategy when pan-frying fish.
4 lbs chicken legs and thighs with skin on
4 Tbs butter (add more if necessary)
1 tsp salt
1/3 cup Aunt Jemima Pancake Mix
1/8 tsp red pepper powder (adjust to your taste)
1 cup chicken stock
1 cup water
2 medium onions cut ¼ inch thick
25+ baby carrots or cut up larger carrots
1 can artichoke hearts
6 whole cloves
15 whole peppers, crushed
8 stalks Celery, cut thick
10 Mushrooms (large), halved
1½ cup Bisquick
¼ cup milk
½ cup light cream
- Toss the chicken in the flour, salt, pepper mixture. Dry the chicken first, and don’t put it all in the bag at the same time. If you are very calorie conscious, you can remove the chicken skin.
- Brown the chicken, skin side down first, in the butter in a dutch oven. You will not be able to fit all the pieces in the pot at the same time. Make sure that the skin is quite brown. Remove the pieces to a side dish with paper towel to drip.
- Put the cloves, peppers, onions, and baby carrots into the butter, and sauté about 5 mins. Stir occasionally, and deglaze the bottom of the pot with some of the water.
- Add the soup and the remaining water; bring to a boil; and add the chicken back. Cook, covered, on low about 30 minutes.
- Add the celery and mushrooms, and cook an additional 5 minutes. (If they are added early, they will become soggy.)
- Mix the Bisquick, egg, and milk, and put tablespoons full (there will be about 6) onto the chicken above the liquid. Cook uncovered 10 minutes.
- Cover, and cook an additional 10 minutes.
- Gently remove the dumplings, and thicken with the remaining flour which has been mixed with the light cream. Remember–flour can only be mixed with cold liquid.
- Return the dumplings to the pot for serving.
- If this recipe is done with boneless chicken breasts, reduce cooking by ~10 minutes.
John says that it was his mother who inspired his love of cooking and baking at an early age. (She cooked vegetables in boil-able packages.)